Work-in-Progress

[Hunting for a good quote]

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

The point of all these is?

It was drizzling in the evening. I started jogging back before the droplets on my shirt joined together to form a big wet patch. Between panting and stitches and thinking how beautiful the sun is when it’s at it’s softest, I thought of the Laos kids playing in the rain. Dipping themselves in the newly-created pool, hair wet, bodies cold, playing those jumping games they always play.

It was a happy and sad thought, being able to re-visit and not relive. There is an old man in the documentary: Invisible City who showed black-and-white photographs of police hitting students from the Chinese schools then, and he retorted something of the like to the black video filming his angry face, “If something is not recorded, did it not happen? Read all the history textbooks, they say Chinese students were violent. Tell me who is violent, look.” Last week’s lecture on Lim Chin Siong being erased from the official history in our secondary school education and the whole issue of alternative histories ties together with memories and perhaps our obsession with documentation.

“If something is not recorded, did it not happen?” We need to click away, to capture an emotion or an ambience, so that there comes a day when we can look at the photograph in it’s real, glossy, physical form and say, “It happened. I remember now.”

-But technology is very dangerous. Cameras, vidoes, blogs, they leave some traces of flavour behind, without being able to record it's entity, so that on that one day when you re-visit, it becomes an exaggeration or a romanticization.

9 comments:

Charles Sng said...

I guess no matter what, records are evidences that events happened. They are only means to refresh our memories.

It is ultimately the human minds that distort, due to ambition, desires, longings, fears....

Rubber Dust said...

: )

anyway, charles, thank for helping out, i REALLYYY appreciate it a lot. saves me the trouble of sourcing for someone else. i'll NEVER call you old again. haha i hope.

Harrison said...

There's always a need to provide a more concrete alternative from videos, films and photos from events of the past - the rigorous process of fact-checking, archival compilation, cross-referencing in order to present a more objective, factually-supported perspective.

Although words are just as subjective in their meaning and therefore as manipulable as visual aids such as photos, as sentient beings capable of intellectual thought and reasoning we should be able to spot discrepancies in facts and point them out so as to prevent deliberate corruption and obfuscation.

However, many are still obviously more influenced and vulnerable to emotional stirrings - hence, the propagandistic videos and posters of the Maoist and Stalinist era that play on that irrational Marxist sentiment of collective consciousness. You're right in that concluding sentence about exaggeration and romanticisation: simplified into its basic components, that is exactly the essence of propaganda.

Learning about Lim Chin Siong? That's great! He used to be the next PM of Singapore.

Anonymous said...

hey, actually i don't know the point of all this. but it is unforgettable! =)

Anonymous said...

Lim Chin Siong?

i smell a whiff of conspiracy theories and Nation Building SSA2204.

Rubber Dust said...

hello harrison, haha, yes you're right, according to LKY, he used to be eh. i guess you're right, the need to record and the inevitable distortion.

hello guan, 203 SUCKS.(MY TURN ON MY BLOG! WHAT CAN YOU DO?:D)

zhihan, what's nation building about? is that a geog module? we did lim chin siong in ssa1201, soci mod.

Harrison said...

Funny how Al Gore also used something to that effect, whenever he introduces himself in that same manner, "I used to be the next President of the US."

SSA2204 is cross-listed under History, and it's a pretty interesting module for sure. LCS was the personality of that period in pre-independence Singapore: the man who could work the ground, especially when he could speak fluently in dialect while LKY was still conversing mainly in English, hence the obvious rivalry, and also LKY's eventual taking-up of Chinese .

But of course, they can all speak of LCS the way they want, praise him to the moon, but the fact remains that he's gone from the scene. A "hero" post-mortem, when he was labeled as a Communist front-man and thus an enemy of the state for most of his political life.

Rubber Dust said...

-spoken like a true PS major. : )

elevenztwelve@gmail.com said...

May I be so bold to suggest that evidence and history doesn't exist? Cuz it always ends up to be 'evidence' and 'history' instead!
;)